Videos > Ansys Motor-CAD: LAB Torque Speed Curves
Apr 25, 2024

Ansys Motor-CAD: LAB Torque Speed Curves

Hello everyone, David Giglio here with Ozen Engineering, Inc. In this video, I will show you how to use Ansys MotorCAD to develop torque-speed curves and analyze how the losses of the motor affect the power output at high speeds.

Getting Started

  1. Navigate to the drive where Ansys MotorCAD is installed.
  2. Go to the tutorials folder and select the BPM design traction folder.
  3. Open the IPM traction lab torque-speed project.

Model Setup

In the project, you will find three tabs: Model Build, Calculation, and Electromagnetic.

Model Build Tab

  • Under the Model Options sub-tab, configure the saturation and loss models.
  • The saturation model has three types:
    • Fixed Inductance Type: Uses LD, LQ, and neutral flux of the air gap to calculate electromagnetic performance. Values are fixed and do not change with current magnitude or angle.
    • Single Step: Built on D and Q axis flux linkages, evaluated at a single rotor position.
    • Full Cycle: Evaluated across multiple electrical cycles, using the same points per cycle as the torque calculation in the electromagnetic model.
  • The loss model types include:
    • Neglect Model Type: Ignores iron, magnet, sleeve, and banding losses. Only DC phase resistance is considered for copper losses.

Note: The neglect model type is recommended only for initial machine sizing and design optimization due to low accuracy.

Example Configuration

  • Use the Single Step saturation model with coarse resolution (15 points).
  • Select the Neglect Model Type for the loss model.
  • Set the DC bus voltage to 720V and the maximum modulation index to 1.

Calculation and Analysis

Electromagnetic Tab

  • Choose the Maximum Torque Per Speed Curve as the calculation type.
  • Set the speed to 15,000 RPM with a step size of 500 RPM, starting from 0 RPM.
  • Build the model, which takes less than a minute.
  • Calculate electromagnetic performance to obtain the torque-speed curve.

Graph Settings

  • Select Shaft Torque and Shaft Power for the Y-axis.
  • Analyze the graph:
    • Below 6,000 RPM (base speed), power output increases linearly with speed.
    • Above base speed, shaft torque decreases, transitioning to constant power.

Advanced Analysis

  • Include AC winding losses and windage losses for a comprehensive analysis.
  • Update the saturation model to Full Cycle and the loss model to FEA Map.
  • Set the maximum modulation index to 0.97.

Conclusion

By controlling the phase advance angle, you can manage torque reduction and speed increase, maintaining constant power output. For further understanding, refer to the textbook Brushless Motors: Magnetic Design, Performance, and Control by Dr. Dwayne Hanselman.

Thank you for watching. Please subscribe to our channel, like this video, and share it. For more information, contact Ozen Engineering, Inc., an ANSYS Elite Channel Partner offering training, consulting services, and ANSYS software packages.

[This was auto-generated. There may be mispellings.]

Hello everyone, David Giglio here with Ozen Engineering. In this video, I will show you how to use ANSYS Motor-CAD to develop torque-speed curves and analyze how the losses of the motor affect the power output at high speeds. In this example, we go to the drive where ANSYS Motor-CAD is installed.

We go to the tutorials folder and select the BPM design traction folder. Inside here, there is an IPM traction lab torque speed project. We open this and then we see this model appear. There are three tabs that we will be using: model build, calculation, and electromagnetic.

In the model build tab, there is a sub-tab model options. We need to set up a saturation model and a loss model. The saturation model has three model types: 1. Fixed inductance type: uses the values of Ld, Lq, and the neutral flux of air gap to calculate electromagnetic performance.

These are assumed to be fixed and not changed with current magnitude or angle. 2. Saturation model single step: built of the D and Q axis flux linkages and how they vary with current magnitude and angle.

These are evaluated at a single rotor position and the D and Q flux linkages are assumed to be invariant of rotor position. 3. Saturation model full cycle: built of the D and Q flux linkages and how they vary with current magnitude and angle.

These are evaluated at average across a number of full electrical cycles. The number of electrical cycles and points per cycle is the same as those used for the torque calculation defined in the emagnetic model.

Under input data settings calculations, the loss model model types include: 1. Neglect model type: iron, magnet, sleeve, and banding losses are neglected in this model type. Copper losses are calculated using only the DC phase resistance.

This option is recommended only for initial machine sizing and design optimization as the accuracy is low. 2. Exhaust valve loss: the loss model model types include the exhaust valve loss. In this example, we are using the saturation model single step and model resolution course with 15 points.

We will select the neglect model type for the loss. Next, we go to the calculation tab and set the DC bus voltage to 720, maximum modulation index set to one, using a motor operating mode maximum torque per amp control strategy.

In the electromagnetic tab, we have the maximum torque per speed curve as our calculation type. We choose the speed of 15,000 rpm with a step size of 500 rpm and it's starting at 0 rpm. This is a maximum RMS current.

Select build model and once we have this model built, we go to electromagnetic, calculate electromagnetic performance. We will then have the torque-speed curve where we can select what curves to choose by going to graph settings plus selection.

We have selected shaft torque and shaft power for the white axis. We can then select the current speed curve and then we can select the phase advanced angle over here.

By controlling the phase advance angle, we can reduce the torque so that as torque is reduced, speed is increased and the back EMF is decreasing. The current is decreasing and the power is decreasing, the product of the speed and the torque achieves the constant power.

We can go back to graph settings and go to instead of shaft torque and power, we can unselect this and select the voltage RMS and phase advanced angle over here. In this example, only the DC losses of the windings are considered, all other losses are neglected.

We saw that the power output was very practically constant. Now, we're gonna run an example of including all the losses. We have opened up an example with the AC winding losses and windage losses considered to compare with the previous example where the only DC losses were considered.

Go to model, emagnetic, input data, losses, and select hybrid FEA. Then go back to model, lab, and update the saturation model type to full cycle and update the loss model type to FEA map. Select AC loss model hybrid method and update the model resolution to custom with the settings shown here.

Then in calculation, we have changed the maximum modulation index to 0. 97. Everything else is the same for the operating mode motor, control strategy, maximum torque per amp. And in the windage tab, we have this automatic calculation for the windage loss model. Now go to the Electromagnetic tab.

We have the same calculation type, maximum torque speed curve selected, the same speed definition, and the same current definition as well. Select calculate electromagnetic performance. Within a few seconds, get the results. And then we calculate the performance.

Thank you very much for listening and watching. Please subscribe to our channel, like this video, share and repost. Thank you very much. Have a nice day.